Archive for category Marketing
Constant Contact Replacement Recommendation: What is Your Favorite Email Marketing Application?
Posted by Dan Katz in Marketing, Online Marketing Best Practices on February 18, 2010
I have used Constant Contact as my preferred email service for medium to small scale mailings for several years. Throughout this time, Constant Contact has served me well with is basic feature set. However, the product development has not kept pace with the changes of Internet communications and I am investigating alternative solutions.
The items Constant Contact lacks that are present in most competitive packages are:
- Multiple levels of list views and segmentation. Constant Contact provides for a simple set of email lists without any segmentation or cross list management capabilities. This is the largest issue in that this requires numerous lists instead of one list with multiple parameters in a recipient profile.
- A varying range of metrics beyond the simple sent, open, click thru and bounce rates.
- A set of comparative trend charts and other metrics for presenting performance comparatively across campaigns. No such metrics are available from Constant Contact.
- Easy removal of the vendor brand. The Constant Contact logo must be requested to be removed from each email and is discouraged.
- Automated click thru tracking of links in email. (Constant Contact requires manual coding to track links in custom HTML emails).
- Ability to create your own email templates. Constant Contact charges a fee and must create such templates themselves.
- Integrated A/B testing of email subject lines and bodies.
- Built-in preview of email layout in email clients. A simple HTML preview is all that is available in Constant Contact.
- Unified billing. Constant Contact charges come to a credit card with little if any detail.
- Cobranded interface. We do not take advantage of the Constant Contact co-branding opportunity because it is cumbersome to setup and manage this brand.
- Google Analytics integration. Constant Contact offers no integration into Google analytics or other statistical packages,
- Free archive and image hosting. Constant Contact charges for the live archive of images and emails. Other packages do not.
- Unlimited custom fields. Constant Contact has a limit of four custom fields.
- Forms integration. Constant Contact offers no form builder or any service to easily create payment gateways for items such as donations.
- Spam filter testing. Constant Contact does not offer an easy test system to check if the emails will violate spam filters.
- CMS integration is unavailable or limited. Constant Contact does not offer or manage plug-ins to common CMS. The few that are available come from third parties.
- API restricted to list management. The Constant Contact API is solely for list import and export.
- Integration with third party tools such as WuFoo for forms, payment gateways, CRM and other technologies without API involvement on the user side.
For a replacement I reviewed numerous packages and selected the following for side-by-side comparisons. (HTML | PDF)
- Constant Contact
- mailChimp
- Campaign Monitor
- Benchmark Email
- Fusemail
- Mad Mimi
- Bronto
- Vertical Response
- Stream Send
- Myemma
- Campaigner
- iContact
- sendloop
Click on the links (HTML | PDF) to see a product comparison table that includes the following vendors. Right now, I am favoring mailChimp and Campaign Monitor. Let me know what you think of these or other vendors. And Constant Contact folks, when you find this, I am by all means open to your suggestions as well.
Wikipedia: An example of democracy and human nature
Wikipedia is no doubt one of the most referenced sites. It also drives a lot of traffic to sites and is always in the top search results for it seams like everything. But there is a public misconception about Wikipedia. Sure we all know the information may not be accurate. What I am talking about is the wrongful belief that anyone can update an entry. This was once the intent. It has failed in practice because of human nature to want to own and control territory.
I have on my personal side gone in and updated points of fact. I have also attempted to enter details (again pints of fact) for clients. They are always erased within minutes by rather militant individuals who through their aggressive editing actions have taken ownership of a set of content. We have found this to be the case throughout Wikipedia.
Example, we updated the mission statement for an environmental non-profit. The old mission statement was there quoted from the Web site. We simply updated it to the current mission that had one line adjusted. This was rejected by an editor because this was “self promotion” by an organization. The old mission now remains on the site.
Slate now has an article about how only a limited few can edit pages of popular people. This is no surprise to many people who already know that editing within Wikipedia is actually tightly controlled. So, what make someone popular? Isn’t just being in Wikipedia mean that you are noted somehow above the rest of us mere mortals? I imagine that if someone who is mentioned on Wikipedia tried to correct their own birthday or something similar it would be rejected as being “self-promotion.”
Now let the fun comments telling me I do not know what I am talking about begin!
Share presentations for visibility on SlideShare
Posted by Dan Katz in Best Practice, Marketing on June 2, 2009
YouTube is certainly well known for the success it has shown with marketers. Another effective tool is SlideShare. SlideShare offers the ability to post a presentation that others can view, share and comment upon just as you would a video on YouTube. There are a number of similar services, but SlideShare appears to have a solid user base.
Easy to use and requiring nothing more than a PowerPoint deck, SlideShare is easy to test out for marketing and communications campaigns.
What makes this really easy is a nice Microsoft PowerPoint plug-in. This allows you to work with the SlideShare features and post to the site right from within PowerPoint. Get it here.
Marketers Challenge; Gefilte Fish
I am sitting here eating a nice plate of gefilte fish. And it is not even Passover yet. But hey, I find these yummy. Certainly most members of the tribe I meet do not have the same preference for this delicacy. Few if any people really say – “hey, let’s go grab some gefilte for lunch.” This is a food crying out for a good marketing effort. It could start with a social media push to enhance the popularity of gefilte fish. As one site at http://me-eats.blogspot.com/2007/04/grandmas-gefilte-fish-for-pesach.html says, there is a story to tell. Then we could build this buzz to some cool interactive. I see the Facebook application now – send a friend a “fish ball”. Or, I would love to see little chattering gefiltes dancing on a JibJab ecard. Then this could be ready for a giant advertising campaign. We could run something to demonstrate to the world just how lovely ground up fish can be. (Only the good stuff here – it is kosher after all.)
Rise oh rise the understated hero that is the gefilte!
A Social and New Media Specialty Practice Strategy: An Outline for Communications and Public Relations Firms
Posted by Dan Katz in Best Practice, Marketing on August 26, 2008
While the major advertising, communications and public relations agencies have all created digital specialty practices, the medium and small agency still struggles to adapt to the digital age. Competition from these specialty practices as well as that faced from interactive and social media agencies combines with the tight client budgets and lack of comfort with the new medium form traditional practitioners. This combination leaves many agencies still unprepared for the impacts the industry is facing from social media.
These are some thoughts of how a small to medium sized agency can integrated social media practice into their agency. Please by all means comment and let me know your thoughts.
The Success of Social Media
Social media is a success because of the confluence of three factors:
- inexpensive, high-speed Internet access;
- easy to use technologies;
- and the inherent human desire to participate in like minded communities.
Social networking in and of itself is not new and has been studied by academics for decades. Social networking is now exciting as it has been invigorated via the Internet to apply its concepts on massive scales across geographies, demographics and other barriers.
In the long term all agencies will adopt the variety of new communications strategies currently being pioneered by leading-edge agencies and boutique interactive firms. Along this path, PR teams need guidance from specialists to bring the services into the routine operations.
Social media as the focus of a dedicated practice is justified through the market demand for the specialty services of strategic planning and tactical implementation fulfilled via knowledgeable experts. Based upon requests from clients large scale firms such as Fleishman Hillard[i], Edelman[ii], Weber Shandwick[iii] and others have already established such practices to deliver such services to new and existing clients. Many boutiques have sprung up to address requests for services as most traditional communications agencies have not begun to integrate and fulfill these services. These factors demonstrate that the demand exists and models can be adopted to support a social media practice.
Practice Definition
Social media is the current major impact point for online to marketing. In a little while there will be something new in the limelight. Edelman has named their practice “Interactive, Social and Emerging Media” to match this constant state of change. An agency digital practice can have a similar growth pattern. The initial service set can target social media. Over time, these services can be adopted by the account teams as they become routine public relations tactics. Meanwhile, the practice can be profitably pioneering and delivering the “next big thing” such as the importance of high speed mobile and online interactions via a plethora of other devices such as your car dashboard to clients. This adoption timeframe may vary from a few months to a few years. The key factor is that the practice can maintain a leadership position to deliver high performance award winning efforts.
Balance of Practice Business Volume
It should be expected that forty percent of the practice volume would be from add-on sales to clients of the other agency practices. This can establish a set of immediate success stories. At the start of the practice the day-to-day execution of selected routine service delivery would be through the existing account teams. This delivery by existing teams should be expected to be needed until the volume of the practice’s new clients warrants additional specialty service staff. At that time the delivery method should be examined and responsibilities may switch to the practice team.
It should be expected that sixty percent of the practice volume can be for engagements from new clients where delivery is provided via the specialty staff. These efforts should be expected to entail larger scale strategy and implementation efforts or very rapid campaigns for new or exiting clients that require the skills of the practice staff. It can be expected that the breakdown of practice staff would be heavily weighted towards strategy and communications experts with design and technology being routinely implemented through freelancers or agencies.
Services
The following is a list of expected services that can be further developed as the core deliverables from the practice:
- Strategic Guidance and Planning
- Social media
- Social networks
- CGM monitoring
- Blogging
- Branded, Corporate, Executive, product, Crisis, Issue
- Videos, vodcasts, podcasts
- Maps, widgets, dashboards and other features
- Mobile marketing and outreach
- Blogger Training
- Executives, communications team members
- CGM/Blogger Relations
- CGM Monitoring and Measurement
- Social network and community activation, monitoring and management
- Creation of dedicated and participation in existing networks
- SEO/SEM
- Blog, social network
- Wiki/Blog establishment and management
- Strategy
- Setup/establishment
- Audience development and promotions
- Content/authoring
- Monitoring
- Measurement
- Activity awareness
- i.e. Twitter, Social bookmarking (Digg, etc.)
- Media center and press release optimization
- Vodcasts/podcasts
- Campaign Web sites and micro-sites
Baseline Services for Existing Clients
Initial sales should be targeted through the development of a base package of services codified and presented to existing clients to be adapted to their needs to deliver immediate social media impact to their programs. These would include:
- RSS feed(s) for outbound news -press releases and a new outlet for news not considered suitable for a press release
- Improved linking practices in press releases to related product and service pages on their Web site
- Interactive press release distribution over wire services for online indexing
- LinkedIn® and Plaxo® accounts for key communications personnel
- Facebook and MySpace pages for the company and key products, services, alumni (employee or customer) supplemented with brand and business driving social networking applications
- Social networking and blog strategies
- CGM (Consumer Generated Media) monitoring
- Twitter®/Friendfeed® feed setup and preparation for use in campaigns and crisis communications
- Interactive maps and related application strategies
- Mobile strategy and Web site and email optimization for mobile devises
- Email newsletter optimization for inclusion of social networking tie-ins and improvements.
- Media center improvements for inclusion of social networking
- General campaign input for all projects cycled through the agency
Sales and Marketing
The expectation should be for this unit to be self supporting in six to eight months. This would require an aggressive new business development approach with matching marketing focus to demonstrate leadership, approach and expertise. The first few months would focus on immediate wins with existing clients. These early success stories would then be matched with a marketing campaign to illustrate to prospects the agencies capabilities and track record. These new business efforts could include:
- Aggressive outbound prospecting and meeting schedules
- White papers to demonstrate leadership, approach and expertise
- Speaking engagements at target market industry events
- Demonstrate strategies through the agency’s own marketing efforts
- Case studies built upon initial delivery to existing clients and new client engagements.
- By-lined article placement in advertising, marketing and public relations industry publications and blogs
- Guest authoring and commenting on respected communications blogs
- PR Practitioners Guide to Social Media – An agency branded practical guide to getting started building and growing communities for communications professionals.
Staff
The initial staffing solution would include a director and two existing staff members. One or both of these staff members should be expected to leave the agency in the first few months of the plan. For the director to drive marketing and new business efforts as well while also conducting the initial service delivery it is important that at least one junior staff member be available as a dedicate practice resource. The skills should match those currently exhibited by staff to complete such tasks as:
- CGM Monitoring and reporting
- Editorial – blog post authoring
- Blogger relations – media relations with specialty on techniques to form relationships with non-traditional journalists and individuals
- Social network participation (i.e. Facebook, MySpace, Twitter, Digg)
Partners
Most efforts would be expected to be executed via an in-house design team’s efforts applied to technology by individual freelancers or very small shops of animators and technologists. Larger scale efforts such as micro-sites and dedicated communicates would be delivered via execution contracts with boutique agencies that could be called upon for their specialties. It should be expected that a formal partnership with an interactive agency would be required in year two.
[i] Fleishman Hillard has been reinvigorating its Digital practice with an emphasis on social media with recent hires in DC and New York. Read more about this practice on their Web site at http://www.fleishman.com/client-solutions/digital.html.
[ii] Edelman established its practice in early 2006. This practice is run by Steve Rubel whose Micro Persuasion blog is one of the most popular covering Web 2.0 and its interface with communications. Good summaries of the Edelman practice goals and strategies may be found at http://www.micropersuasion.com/2006/04/accelerating_th.html and http://www.edelman.com/speak_up/blog/archives/2006/01/the_mea_revolut.html
[iii] Weber Shandwick has expanded its online special service under the name of the name “Interactive, Social and Emerging Media. See the following URL for the description from their Web site: http://www.webershandwick.com/Default.aspx/Capabilities/SpecialtyServices/InteractiveSocialandEmergingMedia.